Latest
Home » Elliptical Trainer Buying Guide

Elliptical Trainer Buying Guide

Sole E25 Elliptical TrainerWhy Should you be considering an Elliptical Trainer?

Ellipticals are a cross over between riding a bike and running.  This means that you can enjoy the smooth feel of a bike, without the bumps and joint stress that comes from running.  They really are the best of both worlds!

They work by providing a total body resistance, the arms have to push and pull and the legs are also forcing against resistance.  If you have not already tried it then you will be amazed at how quickly the blood starts pumping!  At the heart of every elliptical is the flywheel.  This is a heavy metal disc that is hidden away safely that is forced around faster and faster by your efforts.  With a good heavy and balanced flywheel all the resistance is delivered smoothly to your major muscle groups.

At the lower end of the market, you have smaller less well ‘balanced’ flywheels.  If you are used to using big expensive commercial machines in gyms and make the transfer to the budget end you will really notice a difference in the quality.

The prices for ellipticals can start as low as $99.  I doubt that at this price you would get anything that gives you a fun reliable workout.  A realistic entry price for an elliptical is about $300-$500 one of the lowest price ellipticals we have looked at is the Body Champ BRM 3689 this retails at $399 and is a good all round elliptical, for the price.

How Much can I expect when I spend more on an elliptical?

The main ways that manufacturers cut corners is as follows:

  • Stride Length – to short and you will not have a full range workout
  • Poor Resistance – Small, Light or Un Balanced Fly Wheel
  • Style of movement – It should be elliptical not round and round
  • Build Quality – An important consideration if your weight is over 200lb

Lets look at these in detail:

Stride Length.

According to the Sole Elliptical Buying Guide choosing the right is the most important decision to make.  If the stride is too long then you will have to stretch too far to complete the motion.  Worse if you are tall and the stride is to short then you will end up moving with small shuffles and not a graceful movement.

If you are not moving through a full range then you are not working the body to the fullest, and getting a proper workout.

Look for an elliptical with a stride length of about 18-20″ and most users will be comfortable.  For example the Sole E35 has a stride of 20″ which is about optimal for most users.

Poor Resistance

The resistance comes from the flywheel.  This is a big spinning disc inside the elliptical that governs how the motion will feel.  When it comes to the fly wheel the bigger the better!  Unfortunately the bigger also means more expensive.  A good balance is to choose an elliptical with a flywheel weight in the region of 25-35lb.  The reason ellipticals start getting more expensive with bigger flywheels is because of all the extra strength that has to go into supporting its weight and the weight of all the bearings and controls needed to support it.

Style Of Movement

The motion of an elliptical should be in a eclipse shape like this shown on the Precor Website:

Elliptical Movement

This movement is designed to minimise stress on the joints, and mimic the movement of the foot when running.  On lower end models this breaks down and the movement is rounder, or less well defined this gives a jerky uncomfortable movement.

Build Quality

With entry level equipment, under $500 you can expect to find a serviceable Elliptical that will work safely.  Push it to hard though and parts will start to wear out quickly.  To cut cost these parts may not be easily replaceable (welded in rather than attached with nuts and bolts for example).  When it comes to arranging a repair then customer service may be poor or non existent!  Lower end models will run with the odd clank, and squeak, the plastic parts will come off and break easily.

Over $500 you should start to find a little more refinement, and of course if you are more happy with the feel of the machine then you are more likely to use it!

When you get over $1000 then aside from sound mechanics then you will also see big improvements in the electrical systems.  The controls will have a nice feel to them, and more thought given to the positioning and ergonomics.

The step up to commercial quality takes place about $2000, at this price you are buying a rock solid machine that can be expected to run 24/7.  Customer support will be excellent, however as the machines are well built I doubt you will be calling them often!

 Summary:

Ultimately its all about compromises. There are many options out there.  Choose your budget and try and find the best model that fits your price.  Some of our recommendations are:

Best Elliptical Under $500:  Schwinn A40 Elliptical Machine

Best Elliptical Under  $1000 ProForm 1110 E Elliptical Trainer

Best Elliptical Under  $2000 Sole Fitness E95 Elliptical Machine

Best Elliptical Under if Money No Object?  Precor EFX 835 Commercial Series Elliptical Fitness Crosstrainer

 

Dual Trainers

Body Champ produce a range of dual trainers, both elliptical and cycling, they are:  Body Champ 2720 reviewBody Champ 3671 review and the Body Champ 3689 reviewed here. 

Leave a Reply